Last Updated on September 2, 2019 by

During the offseason, or even prior to the July 31 trade deadline, we often hear the words ‘trading a player when his value is at its highest.’ I’m here to tell you it’s a matter of absolutes versus what ifs.

I tried to make that exact point on the Texas Rangers this past offseason and suggested a deal centered on shortstop Elvis Andrus. After coming off what was his best statistical season, I had the opinion that the Rangers should put a package deal together to get the piece, or pieces, they needed going into 2013. For what they could get, and for where Andrus’ value was at that point, could the Rangers have landed an ace like David Price or an impact bat such as Giancarlo Stanton? Instead of making such a deal, the Rangers opted to extend Andrus’ contract to carry him through the 2022 season, essentially removing the probability of him being traded anywhere, anytime soon.

The reason I made that particular argument was because Jurickson Profar, the game’s top prospect entering this past season, was patiently waiting his turn to show the Rangers, and the fan base, that he was worth every bit of hype that surrounded him prior to his call up to the big leagues in 2012. His status as an elite talent was the one thing the team was selling during his time in the minors. The club wanted their fans to look forward to seeing Profar in the future because, well, he was the future.

However, signing Elvis Andrus to a long-term deal makes one wonder about whether or not the team is committed to Profar at any level, and what their plans may be for him moving forward.

There has been a lot of talk on the Dallas/Ft. Worth radio airwaves about possibly of trading second baseman Ian Kinsler or moving him to the outfield in order for Profar to have an everyday role with this team, not just another guy coming off the bench.

Here’s the problem with trading Kinsler, even though I brought this exact topic up in a piece I wrote a few weeks ago: The Rangers aren’t likely to get much back in return, at least not the kind of impact players this club needs heading in to 2014 to return to the top of the American League West and make another World Series appearance.

So where does that leave the Texas Rangers? Unfortunately it probably leaves them with a decision that most didn’t believe this team, or front office, really wants to make.

It might be time to look into trading Profar.

With the World Series starting next week, the Rangers will begin putting names up on their theoretical white board and looking into how they acquire those players. As of right now, they have a need for two catchers — both A.J. Pierzynski and Geovany Soto are free agents — a first baseman to replace Mitch Moreland, even though general manager Jon Daniels says he’s not ready to give up on him yet, and a corner outfielder, assuming the team doesn’t give the starting job to Craig Gentry, who is clearly better suited for a part-time job.

There’s no question that Texas doesn’t want to trade Profar, only to see him do what Chris Davis did this past season with the Baltimore Orioles — explode into stardom after leaving Arlington. They don’t want this to turn into another Adrian Gonzalez deal to the San Diego Padres, either.

The two names everyone has wanted to talk about in the past, in terms of trade targets, are Price and Stanton. Each brings star-level impact.

Mike Bacsik, a part of CBS Radio’s “G-Bag Nation” on 105.3 FM The Fan in Dallas, Texas, said during the show that he would be interested in sending Andrus to the Los Angeles Dodgers for outfielder Matt Kemp. That deal may have been, at least somewhat, likely during the 2012 offseason but it seems extremely unlikely now. Or does it? Kemp’s been injured, and Hanley Ramirez is almost certainly better suited to play third base.

Take Andrus out of the equation and insert Profar?

If Profar were to be moved in any deal to any team, it’s not likely to be a one-for-one. Instead, such trades tend to end up as package-driven, and in the end Profar remains ‘prospective’ and unproven, suggesting other players will be necessary, though the 20-year-old is the headliner.

Profar for Kemp? Price? Stanton?

It may not be a popular move, especially with how much we’ve been hearing about the switch-hitting shortstop since he made his state side debut, but if the Rangers have no intention of trading Andrus, and can’t get a solid enough return for Kinsler, does that leave them with much of a choice if they have any plans to regain a spot on the ladder of October baseball?

It’s time for teams to not fear the “what if” about trading young talent, even the elite, if the return nets the absolute impact necessary to win it all. That fear will be the difference between making that one trade that means a great shot at a World Series or hanging onto a prospect that may never live up to the hype.

Latest posts by Jason A. Churchill (see all)


  1. Avatar

    Profar will be worth more when he has proven he can produce in The Show. He may be the #1 ranked prospect but I wouldn’t trade Walker for him right now. The Rays might buy him in a package for Price’s last two seasons but they will be shedding payroll they can’t afford at the same time.

  2. Avatar

    I feel you, and god knows in this day of sports, players have more power than ever. That being said, if Wash and the rest of the team knew that they’d ALL be better served if Kinsler moved to 1B/OF, they too might ‘suggest’ to him that a move wouldn’t be horribly. I mean, let’s face it, Kindler is good, but he is no superstar, and probably isn’t good enough to run a clubhouse based on his skillset.

  3. Avatar

    Lol, than watch Wash be demonized in texas and Management fire him. Won’t happen you don’t mess up team chemistry and a pissed Kinsler will lose Wash the Club House.

  4. Avatar

    JAC- I have read the same thing, and my phiosophy if I was in charge of the Rangers would be something like this:

    Wash: Ian, you’re hitting 2nd and playing 1B tonight
    Kinsler: Skip, we’ve been over this, I don’t want to play any position other than 2B
    Wash: Ian, you’re hitting 2nd and playing 1B tonight
    Kinsler: WASH, I don’t want to!!!
    Wash: Ok, sit, tonight. But, tomorrow, I’ll have the same lineup. Sit again, and the team will have a great case in court as to why they are not going to pay you a dime of your salary.
    Kinsler: But, b-b-b-
    Wash: Hey Ian, STFU!

  5. marinercoug,

    Kinsler is basically refusing the idea. It’s been discussed. It’s not as easy as just doing it when the player wants to be the next Michael Young and always put himself ahead of the team.

  6. Avatar

    Put Profar at 2nd, move Kinsler to 1B/OF… I don’t see what is so hard about that decision for the Rangers

  7. I think the consensus around the league is that if the Rangers can get Price, Scherzer or Stanton for Profar+, they should do it. After that, might be tough to get proper value.

  8. Avatar

    Texas has Andrus on the roster now and he will hold that spot down until one of there MANY young SS in the minors is ready. With players like R. Odor, L. Sardinas, Y. Alonzo any of these 3 guys could be top 3 prospects in any system. All could be stars in the AL at some point. If I was Texas I would trade Profar for a stud and not wait. They have to string a minor league system to worry about it. They need a win in the series more than 5 solid SS.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.