Updated: by

billy butlerAfter slumping through the final months of the regular season and narrowly making the playoffs as a Wild Card team, the Oakland Athletics have added what they hope will be a solution to some of their offensive woes. The club reportedly agreed to terms with designated hitter Billy Butler on a three-year deal worth $30 million on Tuesday night. Butler had his $12.5 million club option for 2015 declined by the Kansas City Royals and did not receive a qualifying offer.

The 28-year old posted a .271/.323/.379 slash line with a 97 wRC+ in 2014. He hit just nine home runs, marking the first time he failed to post a double digit total since 2007. Butler has a career .808 OPS and 117 wRC+ so it’s fair to suggest that this past year was a down season. The slugger provides no value outside of his bat and should continue to be kept in a designated hitter role.

At first glance it is a little surprising to see the A’s commit considerable dollars to a DH, but it was even more surprising to see the club deal their cleanup hitter, Yoenis Cespedes, for an ace starting pitcher, Jon Lester. Despite boasting a loaded rotation and strong bullpen Oakland struggled to win games after the trade deadline. Many pointed to the loss of Cespedes as the reason why the lineup fell apart but at the time the Cuban star had a sub-.300 on-base percentage — he wasn’t the issue. It was more of a collective slump by the bats. Constantly losing games 2-0 or 3-1 isn’t usually the pitching staff’s fault. Everyone in the lineup had to move up a spot and certain players became exposed.

Butler is a career 142 wRC+ against left-handed pitching compared to a 108 wRC+ against right-handed pitching but his salary suggests that he won’t find himself in a traditional platoon situation. Manager Bob Melvin has been known to get creative with his lineup so nothing is out of the question.

The slugger was thought to be a prime target of the Seattle Mariners this winter, not solely because he’s a designated hitter, but because of his ability to crush left-handed pitching. Butler would’ve fit well in the M’s lineup, likely between left-handed stars Robinson Cano and Kyle Seager. The M’s do have cash to burn and were willing to give DH Corey Hart up to $13 million in 2014, but at this time it seems likely they found the third year to be prohibitive.

A salary in the $10 million range didn’t appear to be out of the question for Butler this winter but the three guaranteed years is a little surprising. He’s still young enough — he’ll turn 29 in April — that he could have taken a one-year deal to rebuild his value and sought a more lucrative multi-year deal next winter. But if the former first-round pick paid any attention to what transpired last offseason, those who get too greedy and wait for something better — we are looking at you Kendrys Morales — don’t always find it. Given the scarcity of right-handed power on the market there probably would’ve been another team willing to go three years at some point, but it was smart of Butler to take the now while it was on the table.

One thing we’ve learned during the early stages of free agency this year is the team that comes out aggressive will probably get their man. Obviously Victor Martinez wanted to stay with the Detroit Tigers, but had the club waited longer to offer four years and $68 million it’s possible he would’ve taken a larger deal elsewhere. And even likely had a club gotten desperate after other plans fell through.

Russell Martin was far and away the best free agent catcher available, but a five-year deal worth north of $70 million seemed a little high when it was suggested a couple weeks ago. It’s been reported that the Chicago Cubs, his expected landing spot, weren’t willing to go that high in their contract negotiations. The Toronto Blue Jays, however, made it clear he was their guy and got a five-year, $82 million deal completed. Did they have to overpay a little for Martin? Sure. Factor in the exchange rate of the Canadian dollar and a club policy against no-trade clauses and they probably had to buff up the total dollar amount.

Three years for Billy Butler sounds aggressive and the Athletics probably had the advantage of being the first team willing to go that extra year. Trying to predict free agency and what factors will affect the market each year is nearly impossible. Most higher end free agents prefer to take their time and touring a particular city or cities during that process is not uncommon — a la Pablo Sandoval in Boston this week.

What we have seen in the past though, and are starting to see again this year, is that pushing the extra couple chips into the pile will usually get a deal done early.

And if you were wondering what the Mariners were up to tonight, Bob Dutton has you covered.

Latest posts by Tyler Carmont (see all)


  1. Avatar

    It’s interesting, one of Jim Bowden’s bold predictions for the offseason was the Mariners signing Hanley. When I look at the market for his services there are surprisingly few fits. Dodgers look like they have moved on, Yankees haven’t shown much interest, Mets prefer trade route for a shortstop — there very well could be an opportunity. I don’t think he’s a great fit and I don’t really buy the ‘just stick him in a corner outfield spot in a couple years’ narrative. But we’ll see.

  2. Avatar

    I think the Ms are going to sign HanRam. I could also see them sign Tomas as well. If they sign HanRam then I think they move Taylor for a pitcher.

    That would give you

    Jackson CF
    Ackley LF
    Cano 2B
    HanRam SS/DH
    Seager 3B
    Tomas RF
    Morrison 1B
    Miller DH/SS
    Zunino C

    P traded for Taylor

  3. Avatar

    Whenever rosterbation trades are explored, there is the invariable suggestion that the deal must include the incoming player signing an extension to make the trade happen. When was the last time any player that will be a Free Agent after one or two years with the team he will be traded to has ACTUALLY agreed to an extension that eliminated his Free Agent leverage. In other words perish the thought that Cespedes or Justin Upton will come to Seattle and agree to an extension to help finesse the trade at hand.

  4. Avatar

    IMHO the most logical approach for JZ is to streghten the starting rotation by signing Lester. Then deal Iwakuma for Cespedes and only he agrees to extention. If Boston or Cespedes don’t come to terms then Kemp should be the alternative. Shouldnt cost the oganization alot cosidering Kemps huge contract…just sayin

  5. Avatar

    That’s no tan on Corey , its mercurochrome from his latest injury ….

  6. Avatar

    I wouldn’t worry about blocking Peterson.

    He just reached AA midseason last year, and struggled. He was also BRUTAL in the Arizona Fall League. He likely needs a full season split between AA/AAA in 2015, and is far from a sure thing. The club definitely shouldn’t worry about blocking him. He’s not really that close to the big leagues, and has a lot to prove.

  7. Avatar

    The M’s aren’t getting Cruz, I predict. Kemp or Upton via trade? Seems the most likely to me. Also, Corey Hart is tanned, rested, and ready 🙂

  8. Avatar

    You guys don’t get it, you can’t have Cruz for 3 years!!! To get him you have to outbid Baltimore and give him 4 years. You still want him if he costs 4/60 million or more?

  9. Avatar

    3 years of Cruz > 3 years of Butler

  10. Avatar

    Butler would not have blocked Peterson as he will soon be out performing him before that contract expired, in fact Butler would be behind Kivlehan as well within 3 years.
    Nothing wrong with Cruz , if we had him last year we would have been KC and they would have been playing golf.

  11. Avatar

    I liked Butler for 3/30. He is 29 years old, and you are signing him for his prime years. This is a very trade friendly contract, and look for Billy Beane to flip Butler midway through this deal. I don’t buy the idea that this contract would have blocked DJ Peterson as a result. Now that Martinez and Butler are off the board, the team is left with former PED users Cruz and Cabrera. If Cruz has a 3 year deal in hand from Baltimore, giving him 4 years so he comes to Seattle is CRAZY!!! Please don’t do it Jack! Cruz might have one or two decent years left…

    Does the team not want a DH this year, preferring to use the spot to rest the regular guys? That is the only way let letting Butler go so cheaply (with no draft pick compensation tied to him) makes sense to me…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.